The NEC is the UK’s number-one venue for shows, exhibitions, meetings, and events. Officially opened in 1976, the NEC has grown significantly in size and reputation. Today, the NEC boasts 18 exhibition halls, a performance arena, 32 conference suites and a host of additional outdoor spaces. These flexible areas host over 2.3 million guests and over 500 events every year and are included as one of the venues for 2022’s Commonwealth games.
B L Acoustics have over 30 years of expertise in life safety systems and were gratified to equip the venue with a leading range of new Public Address and Voice Alarm equipment. Our mission to replace the site’s outdated system began in 2019 with our team completing design specifications, site surveys and design engineering/reviews.
Technical Overview
The existing PAVA system at the NEC was distributed across the site with equipment operating in twelve locations, all interconnected by a fibre cable network, with most areas equipped with a local microphone used for making announcements. The existing system operated using a combination of four sets of apparatus, three of which were at the end of their design life, but all critical to the operation of the PA system and, therefore, the use of the building. The outdated control system and Cobranet devices located in a central point made up the routing system for the entire site. As such, it was necessary to upgrade the two elements as a single package.
With a view to enabling future upgrade works, we suggested an initial upgrade phase (Phase 1 of 3) that would consist of the following:
– Replacement of the GUI control points
– Replacement of media matrix audio routing
– Implementation of temporary serial servers at remote racks (allowing decommissioning of the serial bridges)
The replacement audio routing equipment, as part of this initial phase, would be physically located in a central location but would allow us to move to a distributed architecture over the course of the remaining phases.
Project Plan & Installation Phases
Phase 1 would involve the installation of the temporary serial servers which would not affect the operation of the existing equipment. The security user GUI and the administrator GUIs would be installed alongside the existing panels.
Phase 2 would see the installation of the ASL Vipedia’s into a temporary central location, which again would have no impact on the existing system. Inputs to the Vipedia system would be paralleled from the audio connections to the media matrix units. The media matrix unit outputs would be paralleled to wiring looms ready to connect to the Vipedia’s. Testing of the routing system would be completed alongside the existing system using the same inputs via the new control system and GUIs. This parallel method of operation meant the new system could be changed over without any loss of operation of the system and allowed the site to operate normally.
Phase 3 would involve the relocation of each of the Vipedia units to remote locations where they would be connected to the IP network switches as well as the secure fibre loop. At this point, the audio distribution and architecture were changed and operating across the new equipment, but feeding the existing amplification
Phase 4 involved a series of rack upgrades across each rack location, replacing the existing amplification with compatible ASL V2000 amplification and creating a harmonized EN54 voice alarm solution.
System Description
The new voice alarm system was designed to be fully monitored and compliant across the 12 equipment locations on site. The distributed system was connected via a newly installed closed fibre loop network used only for the PAVA system. The system comprises the ASL Vipedia range of equipment and associated ASL V2000 amplification, with each of the six V2000 chassis’ individually battery backed by 24V stacks mounted in the base of the racks.
Along with the central equipment, each location was fitted with a new local microphone—three new security microphones with touchscreen controllers were also installed.
The existing organiser panels in each hall were retained and reused, which provided inputs for background music and existing single-zone paging microphones. This routing could be dynamically changed using the admin control PC in the central location. A unique solution for a voice alarm system made possible by specially designed software by our in-house engineers.
Emergency messages were primarily stored in the audio router but were also stored and played locally in each remote audio router. The emergency and non-emergency messages could be manually triggered from the touchscreen control panels.
The system also featured an additional message player for storing and playing back other non-emergency messages. The user can load pre-recorded messages to this device or record directly from one of the desk microphones. Messages could also be scheduled to broadcast automatically to any configuration of zones.
In the event of a touchscreen failure, the ASL MPS10 desk microphone could be used independently. Grouped zone buttons on the microphone base provide backup functionality in an emergency.
The existing 100v loudspeaker network cabling was reused in all areas, with existing loudspeakers also retained. Excluded from this was the Skywalk, whose loudspeakers were upgraded with higher performance EN54 units, so music could be broadcast to the area, something the existing loudspeakers were not suitable for.
Fault monitoring was governed by each audio router; a display on the front of each unit showed the status of the local equipment and an overview of the faults across the network. This information was also logged on the aforementioned admin PC.
The admin PC is used to determine the routing of background music and the organiser’s microphones based on the requirements of the venue and the events that are in place. It also serves as a secondary fault display and system logger and manages the messages available to the user interfaces.
Organiser Microphones
Existing panels located in specified areas across the site provide the facility (individually) for multiple microphone(s) to be plugged in. Specially designed hardware interfacing was developed to allow audio and control to be implemented over the limited existing single-pair cabling.
Background Music
These existing panels can also facilitate the addition of a background music source. The audio pairs were wired back to the rack and directly through to the inputs of the Vipedia. Each BGM input is routed based on the routing made by the admin PC.
Installation Challenges
Changeover works were set to begin in 2020; however, these came to a grinding halt upon the outbreak of the COVID-19 virus. The NEC became a vast new temporary field hospital accommodating 500 beds in April 2020. The venue would not be available for public or work access until 2021.
Now, the NEC has returned to regular operations, and installation has been completed by BLA. The new system is functioning as expected.
We have an exciting opportunity for a Field Service Technician to join our team. B.L.Acoustics Ltd operate within multiple areas of the audio industry but primarily within the Public Address & Voice Alarm sector.
We are looking for an enthusiastic and well-organised individual who has an aptitude for fault finding, diagnosing and resolving technical problems. You will deal directly with customers and attend a variety of different sites across the UK. This is a full-time position (Monday to Friday) and requires work to be carried out outside the company‘s core hours. This includes night or weekend work, allowing the applicant to earn substantially more than their basic wage.
The successful applicant will receive on-the-job training on the various systems we maintain. An interest in audio systems or similar electronic systems would be preferred, and experience from other industries in communications and electronics will be considered.
Area of Responsibility & Key Activities
– Service and maintenance of PAVA systems
– Reactive maintenance of PAVA systems
– System upgrade works and system programming
– Providing visit/fault reports
– Basic acoustic measurement and analysis
– System installation
– Out of hours working and call out cover on a rota basis
Education level and/or relevant experience(s)
– Relevant engineering qualification would be preferred but not required
– Full UK driving license
– Good IT skills
Personal qualities (general and technical)
– Strong fault-finding skills
– Able to lead from the front with a visible ‘can do’ attitude.
– Self-motivated and able to work without full supervision
– Strong numeracy and literacy skills
– Personal drive and determination to achieve success.
– Must have a confident and professional manner in front of customers.
To apply, please click here: https://www.linkedin.com/jobs/view/2644825883
As incumbent maintainers and installers of the PAVA Systems at the ICC Birmingham, BL Acoustics were engaged to further upgrade the Voice Alarm systems for the newly refurbished Symphony Hall.
The specification required high-performance Music Routing for the Performance Spaces and Bars by utilising the existing sound systems where possible.
Music was routed via the Bosch Voice Alarm system using Symetrix AV Processing Controllers.
For the main Performance Space, we installed four HK Audio VORTIS 2 EN54 rated Loudspeakers providing a powerful & superb quality sound in combination with the Bosch Praesideo Voice Alarm Amplification.
Fourteen music inputs were distributed throughout Symphony Hall providing a great deal of plug and play flexibility with the Symetrix System routing any input to any output.
Input panels were constructed using the single gang MK Edge Brushed stainless panels as the standard. We would implement the use of two types of panels; one would have a single XLR input and the other a 3.5mm mini jack input.
Flexible Control
The Symetrix ARC-3 Control Panel provided simple control of each input panel/music source to multiple zones throughout the Symphony Hall Foyers and Performance Spaces.
Design Verification & Modelling
The expansion included the fitting of new bars in each of the lobby areas on Levels 3, 4, 5 and 5A, a new performance space and 2 hospitality rooms on level 5A.
As part of the project, we were commissioned to design and install voice alarm coverage to the acoustically unique space, specifically the performance area with its high open ceilings and full length glass exterior wall which presented significant challenges to intelligibility. Being integrated with the Voice Alarm system, the project specification necessitated the use of EN54 approved loudspeakers only.
Before we could commence physical works, Computer Simulated Modelling of the prime areas for new coverage needed to be carried out to give evidence of design and to plan the equipment and cabling requirements. A computer model (Catt Acoustic 9) was used to create the three-dimensional environment which was then compared in performance to the specified requirements.
Specification
The specification gave a target of band ‘G’ 0.48 STI or better for 80% of the area exceeding 85dBA.
Reverberation
Our model implemented surfaces that were approximated to the surface types used in the building. These would provide prolonged activity for sound in terms of reverberation. We distributed the reflective and absorptive surfaces accordingly and checked the reverberation levels were in line with what would be expected for the space.
The Model
Our Catt model was a complete model of all areas. This enabled us to model a large number of options, should they be required. The model was run several times to see the most optimum position and direction of the speakers.
RESULTS
Proposed System Performance
As stated in the specification, the system was expected to meet band G in 80% of the spaces. The most acoustically challenging space, as afore mentioned, was the performance area. Here, we specified 4 high power cabinet speakers capable of delivering the sound pressure levels and performance required to give clear coverage across the atrium.
For the Hard of Hearing
The Performance Space on Level 4 was fitted with a large 16m x 12m Seven Segment Induction Loop powered by UNIVOX Audio Systems. This was installed beneath the oak floor so as to be undetectable. An audio feed was provided to the loop from the PAVA rack BL Acoustics were installing in Hall 2. This would enable both audios from the Performance Space systems and from the Emergency PAVA to be transmitted onto the loop.
Completion
The installation exceeded the clients’ expectations and offered a massive cost saving by utilising much of the already existing amplification and loudspeakers.
B L Acoustics are proud to add another notch to our belt, having successfully completed the replacement of the public address and voice alarm systems at the (formerly named) Arena Birmingham. The old systems were replaced with Bosch Praesideo EN54 compliant systems communicating via a site-wide optical network installed and designed by BLA.
Utilita Arena Birmingham is an indoor arena and sporting venue with a capacity for 15,800 people. Each year (excluding lockdown), the venue hosts over 100 live events and welcomes half a million visitors through its doors. In 2018 the venue underwent a major renovation with remodelling of the concourse areas and public realm.
A site maintenance visit highlighted several issues with the site’s PAVA system. The main issue was the lack of audibility in certain areas during an evacuation, particularly the main concourse area. The audibility problems were caused by a combination of high noise levels from the smoke extract fans and unsuitability of the loudspeakers installed as part of the renovation project
B L Acoustics have been maintaining the systems at the ever-developing site for many years which helped us to acquire substantial site-specific information which proved to be valuable throughout the complex installation. This benefit enabled us to recognise that maintenance visits before 2019 continued to report existing and new issues across the system with some components beyond their recommended life.
Our Proposal
A solution was designed for the problem areas and modelled using acoustic modelling software. More suitable loudspeakers and an improved layout was proposed and installed to produce much improved audibility even when the smoke extract was running. The increased power requirements of the new loudspeaker layout design had an effect on the rest of the system as higher power loudspeakers require more amplification, and more amplification requires higher capacity battery support.
Our proposal offered replacement equipment which would have the capacity to support the improved loudspeaker coverage throughout the building. This would include the installation of a new high integrity fibre cable network between each of the equipment locations. As well as changing the loudspeaker layout in the concourse areas, each voice alarm loudspeaker across the site was upgraded to new EN54 variants.
During the operation of the aforementioned fans, the SPL level would need to be a substantial level, which would be too high for normal PA announcements. The system includes for ambient noise sensing in the concourse areas to allow the full potential of the system to be used when the fans are operational but keeps PA announcements at a comfortable level during normal operation.
One of the major priorities our client expressed was that the systems could remain in full use throughout the replacement process. The venue is an extremely busy one, meaning that downtime of the system would have been unacceptable and hazardous to life safety.
System Replacement
The completed project was a result of thirty days/nights of work, involving multiple phases of installation, commencing with the fitting of a new resilient loop in fire-rated cable across the site. To ensure the site remained operational throughout the installation process, temporary audio and control links were fitted between the new and existing systems so that both systems could operate concurrently while circuits were switched over from the old system to the new.
Microphone Panels
The old system had both emergency fireman’s microphone and paging microphone units located in various positions throughout the site. B L Acoustics provided replacement units and in the case of the fireman’s microphone provided re-engineered panels which were custom-built to fit their location.
Loudspeakers
Choosing loudspeaker types was critical to the project with tight specifications to provide key criteria:
– EN54 Compliance
– Acoustic Performance
– Aesthetics
– Programme Windows
All loudspeakers were replaced to meet the latest EN54 standards; compact Bosch ceiling loudspeakers were utilised in most areas.
PAVA System Variations
There are many different manufacturers of Public Address and Voice Alarm systems and consequently many different designs.
Deciding on the type of system best used in any particular environment can be determined either by the client or by B.L. Acoustics.
The type of system wanted can have dramatic consequences on the cost of both the system itself and the installation.
Great care must be taken when making these decisions.
B.L. Acoustics has the advantage of understanding and choosing from many different system manufacturers to offer the best solution.
Here are just a few designs detailing their advantages.
Centralised System
Figure 1 shows a typical Voice Alarm System which uses a high frequency tone to monitor the presence of equipment. The tone, which is a high enough frequency not to be heard is fed through the loudspeaker lines to the end of line modules, these then report back to the fault monitoring panel to confirm they are still intact.
Likewise the Fire Interface, Fireman’s Microphone and the Security Microphone generate the same high frequency signal which is detected by the Audio Routing Matrix and then reported to the fault monitoring panel.
This is an extremely reliable system but loudspeaker lines cannot be spurred off and cable installation can be expensive if required over large sites as all the lines arrive at and originate from a single source i.e. the equipment rack.
De-Centralised System
The system detailed below in Figure 2 works on an entirely different principal in that it is comprised of multiple stations which are linked together in a ring, each of which provides amplification to their own respective area.
Each station is networked via a single cable enabling information to travel in both directions.
If the link were to become detached at a single point, the information would communicate from the other direction upholding the system integrity.
Microphones and interfaces can be integrated at any station.
This system has a high degree of integrity and provides an ideal solution for larger buildings or sites with multiple buildings and avoids the huge cost of loudspeaker cabling to a central source.
In addition to the two main concepts shown above, there are many different ways in which the systems internal functions can operate.
These also have a bearing on the overall costs and abilities of the systems.
The Programmable Audio Routing Matrix
The programmable audio routing matrix allows any mic or line level inputs to address any configuration of the outputs, predetermined by the programming of the processor.
The buttons on the microphone or contacts from the Fire Panel will simply initiate the programmed route for the audio to take.
Each input can be programmed with a priority level.
This system is very flexible but is generally more costly.
Output Relay Selection
Output Relay Selection is a simple and low cost alternative used for Public Address systems.
This cannot be used for Voice Alarm.
The inputs can sometimes be prioritized providing a hierarchy structure to the building.
Inputs are switched using either dry contacts or low voltage and the zone selection, once set, cannot be easily reconfigured.
Input Output Mixer Modules
This type of mixer can be programmed using internal hard wired settings such as removal link configurations.
This enables a fairly flexible but low-cost solution for Voice Alarm Systems.
However, each module can only be programmed with one configuration. Reconfiguration of the programme can be difficult and may require lengthy site visits from qualified engineers.
Programmable Input Output Mixer Modules
This system is similar to the system shown above but has the added advantage of being programmable.
This provides for less service time if the programme were to require change, although would still require an engineer to attend site.
Surveillance Variations for Monitored Systems
Differences in the type of monitoring used can affect the cost of the loudspeakers and the installation.
In addition it will determine the flexibility of the loudspeaker cabling routes.
Monitored Tone
This type of monitoring uses either a high 20kHz or low 30Hz frequency which cannot be heard over the loudspeakers.
The signal is sent via the amplifier down the line and received by the end-of-line monitor.
When the monitor receives the signal it generates its very own signal and sends it back down the line to the amplifier.
The signal that is sent back is recognized by a detection unit and reports OK.
If the signal path is broken or shorted against anything, the end-of-line monitor will report a different type of signal which the detection unit can recognize as a particular type of fault.
The surveillance signal can either be continuous or pulsed but pulsed is a preferred option because the amplifiers need to be active to send the signal through, and if they are only active for brief periods then the amplifiers are more energy efficient.
This type of monitoring does not require capacitors fitted to loudspeakers but does require an earth return wire.
The loudspeaker cables do not need to return back to the central equipment and cannot be spurred off into other circuits.
Faults on individual loudspeakers are not always detected although this is not normally a problem if the system is regularly maintained.
Residual Current Detection
Residual current monitoring relies on a current window set by the detection unit and a current generated by the end-of-line module. If anything should change on the line causing fluctuations in the current then a fault will be detected.
The advantage of this system is that it will detect faulty loudspeakers but the disadvantage is that many non-serious anomalies can be detected giving rise to unnecessary call outs and therefore cost.
Impedance Monitoring
This system again uses a high frequency signal fed via the amplifier and the detection unit monitors the impedance measure from the loudspeakers and cables.
A window is set on the detection unit and if the measured impedance moves outside of that window a fault is detected.
This system has the advantage of not requiring end-of-line modules and the loudspeaker circuits can be spurred.
The disadvantage is that in order to reduce the amount of unnecessarily reported faults, the window quite often needs to be set such that faults that do occur are not detected until there are several other faults also.
Direct Current ( DC ) Monitoring
A DC voltage is injected onto the loudspeaker line and at the end of each line a fixed restive value is added to total the amount that the detection unit is expecting to see. The system will detect line failures reliably but will not detect loudspeaker failures.
The advantage of this system is that a number of spurs can be used — typically a maximum of eight.
The disadvantage is that the system requires capacitors to be fitted to each loudspeaker, this can add a slight cost to the loudspeakers and can cause problems when using noise masking systems, as the capacitors also act as a filter at certain frequencies.
Frequency Doubling
This is a very reliable system but is not commonly used.
A 20kHz signal is fed via the amplifier to a unit at the end of the line which then converts the signal into a much higher frequency and sends it back to be detected by the detection unit.
This system cannot be used with spurred circuits.
To know what system would suit the requirements of your business, B L Acoustics can provide non-obligatory quotes.
